The Subwoofer DIY Page
Air Suspension Theory
last updated: 12 October 2018
The Subwoofer DIY Page

 

While searching through my Basslist archives, I came across this message thread that displays the lighter side of some of the list members. Thought I'd repost it for the newbies who joined after the thread was posted :-).

Q: One thing I've wondered is how often everyone else on this list changes the air in their sealed box speakers? With powerful woofers, especially 10" or larger drivers, the internal cabinet air seems to wear out within a couple months. I find the sound much "fresher", with "faster bass" and more "palpable presence", after I replace the air in my sealed subwoofer. Frankly, I'm surprised that even high-end speaker manufacturers don't put convenient valves on their boxes for air exchange, but I guess its just a matter of production costs.

A1: Many new models of speakers use a ported enclosure, to allow the air in the enclosure to be refreshed continuously. The air is exchanged whenever a frequency corresponding to the tuning frequency of the port is played, and if you put your hand in front of the port, you can feel the air exchange in progress. That the port helps the speaker to produce more bass is a by- product of its main role in the design.

 

A2: This is one area in which the DIY`er can definitely improve on mass-manufacturing practice.

The best solution I've found to date is the model Aleph-Null controlled diffusion inducer, by Scott & LaForge Ltd. It mounts inside the cabinet, out of sight (they even thought to use a heavily-damped self-adhesive mounting pad, so the device actually helps suppress cabinet-wall resonances!).

The inducer's effect is to increase the osmotic permeability of the cabinet wall, thus allowing a slow exchange of gasses through the cabinet. The effect is designed to be self- limiting and fairly modest - as I recall, a 50% turnover of the air in the cabinet takes about a week with normal levels of use (2-3 hours per day at standard listening levels). The osmotic exchange rate is deliberately kept low enough that the cabinet continues to act as a sealed box at any frequency of conceivable interest to the human ear (unlike e.g. a Dynaudio "variovent", whose flowthrough rate is a good deal higher and which acts as a resistive damper at bass and infrabass frequencies).

It's powered by the audio signal - you hook it up in parallel with the woofer, on the low-pass side of the crossover circuit. Its impedance is in many respects complementary to that of common woofers... typically about 50 ohms, but dropping to about 10 ohms near resonance (which is tunable). The woofer- and-inducer combination presents a nearly flat impedance load to the crossover. It's efficient enough to be used even with low-power "single ended" amplifiers such as the Zen.

It's a well-thought-out, and well-engineered device, and at the price of only 87 quatloos in quantities of 2 or more it's quite cost-effective.

The only problem with it, in practice, is that it won't be invented for another 217 years. I had a hell of a time getting engineering samples.

 

A3: Hah! This shows that you've failed to read Dorkinson's "Loud Woofer Designer's Checkbook". The whole point of sealing the boxes is to keep the air from leaking into the box. Don't you know that air has oxygen in it? If oxygen is bad for speakers wires, imagine the havoc it would cause if it actually got into the speaker! Most people use a nitrogen purge before sealing the speakers, but you can substitute helium for a lighter sound. Some people like nitrous oxide, but when asked to justify this choice, they just start giggling uncontrollably.

 

A4: I'm using a mix of 2/3 air collected on a Cornish moor, and 1/3 from the Oregon Cascades. Harder to get, but a refreshing blend of qualities, and it seems to last longer. I've been tempted to try a dry Australian, but I am afraid of complications from it swirling in the wrong direction due to residual Corleolis effect.

 

A5: Those dandy little air fresheners my grandparents place in their bathroom do wonders to freshen the air. Me, I like the pungent smell of mold so I vetoed my wife's use of them. The best type for speakers are the ones that plugs in to heat up. Glue it to the back of the magnet and you have thermal controlled speaker air freshening !